ETH Zurich's weekly web journal - auf deutsch
ETH Life - wissen was laeuft ETH Life - wissen was laeuft

ETH Life - wissen was laeuft ETH Life - wissen was laeuft

ETH - Eidgenoessische Technische Hochschule Zuerich - Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich
Section: Forum
deutsche Version english Version
Print-Version Drucken
original version

Published: 17.02.2006, 08:39
Modified: 17.02.2006, 08:39
Further opening up
Open Access

By Martin Kröger, D-MATL

I agree that it would be interesting to access all publications online and free of charge. As the editor of a journal I however doubt, that this policy will result in a useful amount of information. Up to 70% of articles submitted to our journal are usually rejected based on referee reports and editorial decision (incomplete data, wrong data, wrong equations, unreadable, wrong nomenclature, bad spelling, wrong journal, etc). If all this material would get published without the everyday's efforts of publishers, printers, referees, editors (publishers and printers cannot work free of charge, of course, while referees and editors do so) nobody would read it. Working efficiently relies on 'approved' contents. Moreover, not all journals are expensive, ours for example is available for a whole university at roughly 200 Euros/year (and free for ETH). Others, eventually, are available for 5000 CHF/year which is in most cases unacceptable. Librarians should check out the price / impact factor ratio before ordering a journal. If we remove publishers and printers and install a software to check the above criteria, however, we could have freely available publications. I hope the software is available soon, another one replacing editors and referees would be also great. I hope we reach this state soon. We, and everybody asking for the 'free' version should sit down and work on the implementation of the software rather than complaining.

You can write a feedback to this article or read the existing comments.

!!! Dieses Dokument stammt aus dem ETH Web-Archiv und wird nicht mehr gepflegt !!!
!!! This document is stored in the ETH Web archive and is no longer maintained !!!