ETH Zurich's weekly web journal - auf deutsch
ETH Life - wissen was laeuft ETH Life - wissen was laeuft


ETH Life - wissen was laeuft ETH Life - wissen was laeuft
Home

ETH - Eidgenoessische Technische Hochschule Zuerich - Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich
Section: Campus Life
deutsche Version english Version
Print-Version Drucken

Published: 10.06.2004, 06:00
Modified: 09.06.2004, 17:14
It’s a man’s world!

By Brigitte Manz-Brunner and Carla Zingg

Why do so many women turn their backs on a scientific career after obtaining their PhD? The usual answers, "There aren't enough women", "Women don't want to" or "Women aren't as career-minded]", don't provide an adequate explanation. The reasons are embedded in the culture of science.

Science is mainly done by men. Men define what science is. Science works in keeping with criteria that suits men, or, to be more accurate, criteria that are commonly attributed to men. There are no formal criteria that exclude women. Nor does it lie on the intellectual capabilities of women – or would anyone claim that women aren't as intelligent as men?

No, the crux of the matter lies somewhere else, namely in the picture we have of a "crack", an alpha personality with outstanding potential. What characterises a crack? How do we imagine true cracks to be? A crack obviously has a razor-sharp intellect, works most of the time, publishes a lot–and only in the most renowned journals, jets around the world from one conference to the next, sits on the most important commissions, ... in short, he lives for science.


The authors

Brigitte Manz and Carla Zingg have shared the title of head of the Office for Equal Opportunities at ETH Zurich since 2000. Both hold ETH diplomas; Brigitte Manz in agronomy and Carla Zingg in forest engineering. Equal opportunity today is more about practical co-operation, says Carla Zingg, "the battle of the sexes is a thing of the past." Above all, at ETH everyone realises that the main thing is to have the best minds, whether female or male, dealing with the complex problems. Nevertheless, that a university needs women, precisely because they often have a different approach is something that still does not meet with unqualified acceptance – even a decade after the inauguration of an Equal Opportunity Office. "Let's be clear about this: no big waves can be generated at a university by equal opportunity issues," says Brigitte Manz. There was an unvoiced, but still very pervasive "yes" echoing around the halls of academe regarding the male fortress of professorships. The corollaries have been around for a long time; the lack of integration of female career paths in academic careers, networks that don't really hold up and obstinate prejudice. Manz and Zingg regard it as one of their most important tasks to seek out and foster female role models. Not only the best men, but the best women, too, should be called to Chairs at ETH, they say. In addition, the office is active in encouraging women scientists to seek out allies by helping them to network, and it also offers mentoring programmes and organises informative events for the younger generation. One current example is the "wandering" exhibition on ETH being shown at Switzerland's grammar schools. The column, which the pair has agreed to do for "ETH Life", reflects the way they work together: they both put their signatures to it.




continuemehr

Carla Zingg (l.) and Brigitte Manz-Brunner; Co-delegates of the Equal Opportunities Office at ETH Zurich.

But the list goes on: he is also boss and mentor, gathers the best young newcomers around him and drives them on to reach their absolute potential, fascinates his students with brilliant lectures, etc., (can any human being really meet such expectations?).

More to the point, can a women live up to the mental picture we have of a crack? If you employ someone or appoint them to a position you don't only judge their performance so far – you also imagine what the potential of the person is. In this respect less trust is placed in women than in men that they will devote themselves to science with life and soul. The few exceptions only serve to prove the rule.

It is supposed that, sooner or later, a woman will have a partner or even a child, thus insinuating that these "external" circumstances will hamper her mobility or reduce her motivation and that she will no longer live exclusively for science. Motherhood and success are not, however, incompatible – proved by the fact that of the 23 ETH female professors, who we recently portrayed with a loose-leaf brochure, 12 of them have children.

Images of women as unsuited to science or other sundry prejudices against them encroach upon the appointment chances of both women and men. If a man throws in his hand he is perceived to be a failure, whereas a women who leaves science does not lose face but cements the ubiquitous prejudice. What is to be done in the face of such stubbornly persistent prejudice – despite refutation by numerous scientific investigations – that is so difficult to dislodge from our minds?

auflistungszeichen Become aware of the stereotyped prejudices that we all carry around in our minds. Get help! For example by looking in on our exhibition "In the skin of Jeanne, in the skin of Jean" (1) and slipping into another role!
auflistungszeichen Appoint more women who, as role models, refute existing prejudice.
auflistungszeichen Hold regular talks with female employees that leave room for a discussion of their career ambitions and possibilities of development.
auflistungszeichen Change science culture so that it includes not only internationality but also more diversity, thus avoiding a monoculture!


Footnotes:
(1) The exhibition "DANS LA PEAU DE JEANNE - DANS LA PEAU DE JEAN" makes a temporary sex-change possible – with no risk and the same chances for both genders. It runs in Zurich from 8th–12th June 2004 in the entrance hall of ETH's main building, accessible: Tues.-Fri. 10 a.m.–6 p.m., Sat. 10 a.m.–4 p.m. Opening: Monday, 7th June 2004, 6.15 p.m. with Brigitte Manz-Brunner and Carla Zingg, joint delegates of the Equal Opportunities Office of ETH Zurich. Homepage: www.equal.ethz.ch.



You can write a feedback to this article or read the existing comments.




!!! Dieses Dokument stammt aus dem ETH Web-Archiv und wird nicht mehr gepflegt !!!
!!! This document is stored in the ETH Web archive and is no longer maintained !!!